SB917 Now to Outlaw Pet Sales in Chula Vista


The Chula Vista City Council will hold their first hearing Tuesday, February 28 on an ordinance which will essentially prohibit the breeding of animals in private homes and will require animals to be sterilized on a second impoundment.

The ordinance also prohibits sales of dogs and cats in pet stores. There is language prohibiting the sales of animals in public (modeled after state SB 917). Concerned citizens are encouraged to attend the city council meeting or contact the council members and ask them not to move this ordinance forward.

Chula Vista City Council Meeting

Date: Tuesday, February 28, 2012

Time: 4pm (Agenda Item #13)

Location: City Council Chambers, City Hall-Building 100, 276 Fourth Avenue, Chula Vista, CA

Chapter 6.22 of the proposed ordinance will require the mandatory sterilization of any animal the second time it is impounded. It allows the City Manager or his/her designee to waive this provision in extraordinary circumstances such as fire or earthquake. The two violations may occur years apart and not be a true reflection of a habitually irresponsible owner. If a dog gets loose one time as a 6-month old puppy and is then accidentally released by a gardener 5 years later, that does not signify a problem animal.

The proposed ordinance defines a “pet seller” as anyone who sells more than two cats or dogs in a twelve-month period. This definition is used by the State Board of Equalization in determining who is required to pay sales tax. The problem in the Chula Vista ordinance is that the city then uses that threshold to decide who is required to abide by kennel requirements. The provisions for kennels are such that a resident who bred a litter of puppies or kittens in their homes would likely be unable to comply.

For example, Sections 6.08.100 (L) and (M) will require that pet sellers have a facility whose interior walls are impervious to moisture and which are able to be readily sanitized. They are also required to have a drainage system to rapidly drain animal excreta. No home environment is likely to meet these criteria. The measure will also require pet sellers to pay for and undergo inspections, at least annually, by city staff. These provisions are completely unreasonable for a hobby breeder who produces a few litters in their home.

***  Question by PD: Where the hell is a normal person to obtain a dog if they can’t buy it, can’t get it online, and can’t find a breeder? AR answer: YOU MUST GET A POUND-RESCUE DOG!!

What You Can Do

Attend the Chula Vista City Council Meeting on Tuesday February, 28th and speak against the proposed ordinance.

Talking points:

  • Chula Vista intake and impound numbers are currently so low that shelter manager Ms. Anton admits that NO adoptable animal is ever euthanized.
  • Punitive legislation that increases fees and fines always results in higher intake numbers. Yet the stated goal of this ordinance is to reduce numbers of impounds and euthanaia
  • Punitive legislation that restricts breeding removes the best sources for healthy, well-bred puppies and kittens
  • Restrictive and punitive pet laws will increase the numbers of puppies smuggled into Chula Vista from Mexico (the city is just 11 miles from the Mexican border). According to the US Border Patrol, over 10,000 dogs and puppies are already being imported into San Diego County each year. Such puppies are bred under unregulated conditions that may well be substandard.
  • Chula Vista needs to implement a TNR program for feral cats. Currently they kill feral cats. (Remember that 70% of killed shelter animals are feral cats)
  • The new regulation restricting public sales by some entities while it allowing others will eventually be challenged in court (Yes, completely true!)
  • The rights of hobby breeders to pursue their hobby are being unreasonably restricted.
  • The rights of store owners to sell pets from well-regulated sources is being unreasonably infringed upon.

PD: We keep saying it but no one listens. SB917 was drafted by HSUS. If that doesn’t get you, nothing will. You might as well be labeled as sheeple.

Now that animals cannot be sold, they cannot be bred, they must be taxed, they must be licensed with fees 10x higher than “sterilized” animals, they must not be in crates or be outside on a cable or inside your car without air conditioning, horses need 15min “breaks” for every hour they work as carriage horses (giving city tours in Philadelphia)–the AR list is ENDLESS.

If HSUS had its way, there could be no movies with animal cruelty depictions (even if fake), there could be no video games with any violence, there could be no zoos, no captive bred exotics, no exotic birds, or reptiles, no selling of reptiles or birds or fish, or mice. And no animals used for food.

Contact the Mayor and City Council members and ask them to oppose this ordinance as drafted.

Mayor and City Council Office
Phone: (619) 691-5044 
Fax: (619) 476-5379

Mayor Cheryl Cox

Councilmember Rudy Ramirez


Councilmember Patricia Aguilar
(Contact via city fax)

Councilmember Pamela Bensoussan


Councilmember Steve Castenada



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s