Shelters Say Don’t Bring Cats to Shelters– They Get Killed Here

Sacramento ‘River Cats’ Troubling To Wildlife, Human Health

Andrew Nixon / Capital Public Radio

Andrew Nixon / Capital Public Radio

Sacramento animal managers say there are as many as 1,000 colonies of stray cats in the county. If you take a walk at sunset in Discovery Park, you might run into one. Cats lounge around near a picnic table with a great view of the Jibboom Street bridge. These furry animals may be cute, but they pose a threat to humans and wildlife.

About a dozen cats laze around a grassy spot near the two river confluence north of Sacramento. It’s dinner time. A van pulls up. The cats run to it. A man pulls kibble and canned food out of his trunk.

The commercial food drop lured honking geese, swooping magpies, multicolored cats. The scene may look pastoral, but county officials say the cats here are a problem.


“I would call them invasive species,”  says Sacramento County Park Ranger, John Havicon.

John Havicon is a Sacramento County ranger of 30 years and says the cats have been here as long as he has. There are about 75-100 of them in the parkway. He says they go after song birds and native birds near the ground. Cats eat the food of other animals, too.

“The hawks, the owls, fox, raccoons they’re all dependent on the same food sources. And the cat is taking those food sources, and so the [wildlife] will tend to go away,” says Havacon. “So we will see less of the wildlife and more cats, or here, more skunks.”

Havicon says the cats here may not have had veterinary care, and they can pass diseases onto raccoons, fox, and other wild mammals. The cats stay where people feed them. Havicon says you can get a ticket for feeding ducks and geese, but not for feeding the cats.

“It’s in [the cat feeders’] heart[s], they just have to take care of these animals,” he says.

Feral Cats -birdkillers

Karen Shapiro is with the UC Davis School of Veterinary Medicine.

“[It’s] a natural human emotion and reaction, but unfortunately we don’t often think about the broad ecological impact that that can have,” she says.

Shapiro says not only do outdoor cats devastate bird and rodent populations, their feces carry dangerous parasites, like toxoplasma. When a cat is infected for the first time, it can shed hundreds of millions of parasite eggs, which persist in the environment for years.

“Toxoplasma is incredibly prevalent in people. It’s thought to infect about one-third of humans globally,” says Shapiro.


Most people who have toxoplasmosis show no symptoms. But the parasite can be fatal to people with compromised immune systems. Toxoplasma has also been linked to schizophrenia and behavior change. And Shapiro says it doesn’t just affect humans.

“So in California, Toxoplasma makes its way into the ocean through freshwater run-off where it infects a large proportion of sea otters. Sea otters are classified as threatened and infectious diseases are an important cause of death in these animals,” Shapiro says.

Contaminated cat poop can wind up in our gardens, our storm drains, and eventually, in our drinking water. Shapiro says the cat population can be managed through neutering and relocation to barns, but cats will still kill other critters and shed pathogens. Shapiro likes cats, but she says feral cats are a problem.

“There is no easy solution. I think as much as possible, we should aim to reduce and eventually eliminate such cat colonies,” Shapiro says.

Toxoplasmosis -graphic


Discovery Park’s ecosystem was not on Doug’s mind when he shared his sandwich with a cat one evening.

“I was bored, I was really fishing. And the cats ran over to me, so I said, ‘Well I’ll share some food with them!” says Doug, who didn’t want us to use his last name.

The cats attracted a small crowd of walkers around sundown, who for the most part, didn’t have a problem with cat feeding.  “I think it’s a free country,” says Terrie Gaines.

“I think it’s their home now, there are so many, I think we have to accept it probably,” says Tom Marr from Sacramento. “I don’t think the feral cats are a problem as long as they’re spayed and neutered,” says Shannon Brinkley. “I like them actually. They’re the river cats, that’s who we are, the river cats.”  [*The Sacramento baseball team is named the River Cats]

Rumors have it a woman regularly feeds the cats, and has at least some of them neutered. Coyotes have been coming around the park — they keep the population down. The county wishes people would take the cats home. But it’s hard to tell when a cat is feral, and when it’s actually someone’s pet.  (see link for full story)


PD:  Yeah, yeah, yeah……’s the new mantra. “Don’t bring cats to shelter because we end up killing them.”  And the stats on the numbers of killed cats is not leveling off, whereas the killing of dogs has dropped over the years quite a bit.   It’s been stated by most AR groups, shelters and even Maddie’s Fund……Well if no one wants them and shelters kill them, what is new about that? It’s been going on for 50 years, 100 years? Many AR groups such as HSUS are not into feral cats, TNR or saving them, so NOT killing cats in shelters means they are left outside?

Many cat rescues with adult cats simply cannot get homes for them. Not that there is anything wrong with the cats. In cities where there seem to be fewer adult cats, some shelters only have 10 and 12yr old cats which no one wants. In areas such as Sacramento, Butte County and Kern County, they are routinely killed all right. Because everyone WANTS a kitten. Very few people want to BUY an adult cat for $120 or even $50.  At least in Butte County and some other counties, shelters will GIVE away the animals (even dogs) or only charge $15 or $20– not $150 or $250. And in Sacramento on many Fridays, they will sell cats for $5.00 and get one free on some days. We think they should have that every day so they can get rid of them instead of killing them?

But obviously– it is MUCH cheaper to kill them than to alter them and sell them.  What shelters should do is to provide the altering to kitten litters for no cost, then take the kittens and sell them and then make a law which makes one a criminal to sell kittens or give them away anywhere except if you are the shelter??  Do we think that would make people who own cats have less kittens?  Are you laughing? If a law can be made outlawing the sales of puppies that are NOT shelter animals, conversely the CA legislature or just the city can make up a law outlawing sales of kittens or even cats if they want to— why not? You would have to buy a very expensive permit to sell a kitten or cats. Geez– why not just expand that to only shelters can sell cats? Kittens? Instead the shelters tell people to abandon the cats to the streets [by telling them not to bring to shelters..] Go figure.

*Hint: Groups like HSUS et al, don’t believe in feral cat colonies or TNR; in Los Angeles, they had ended the TNR recommendation at shelters……. our opinion is that by promoting  NOT to bring cats to shelters, the ARs want cats to over run public places, THEN they will blame people for it, THEN they will devise the laws involving cats, and who can keep them, or even own or buy them, and who can or cannot have or make feral colonies, and etc.  Just wait. Handwriting is on the wall.